Supreme MindSupreme Mind
1 · Before filingGatekeeper PilotKnow the expert risk before you take the case.2 · Discovery to settlementExpert Agents LiveEach side’s expert analysis and the settlement value, rerun as the facts change.3 · Expert stageReport Builder PilotYour own expert’s report, faster and harder to exclude.
One record, from intake to settlement.Use it in Claude, ChatGPT, Copilot or Word, freePilotsAPI for your tools
AntitrustSecuritiesCommercialMass TortPersonal Injury & Med MalAll Practice AreasPlaintiff FirmsDefense TeamsLitigation Funders
Expected GainsBenchmarkSample BriefResearchSecurity & Trust
Expert Agent LibraryRule 702 TrackerGuidesHow It WorksFAQ
PricingConnect
Sign inBook a demo

General surgery standard-of-care expert

Expert Agent Library · Medical malpractice · Either side

A general surgeon who says whether a procedure such as a laparoscopic cholecystectomy, hernia repair or bowel surgery was performed and followed up within the standard of care, often after a bile duct injury, a perforation or a missed leak. Courts examine both qualification, under statutes that require recent experience in the same area of practice, and reliability: an opinion resting only on the surgeon's own experience can be excluded when it is contradicted by the literature, though literature is not required in every case.

A brief from this expert agent can be written for the plaintiff side, the defense side, a neutral expert, or both sides' experts on the same facts.

Ask this expertPreview

A preview of this class of expert, built from the public rulings on this page. Ask how the testimony is built, attacked or defended. 20 questions free with a firm email.

Takes a minute; we email you a code.

Questions this testimony turns on

  • Is the complication one that occurs in careful hands, or does it signal a departure from accepted technique?
  • What did the operative report or video show about identification of anatomy before structures were clipped or divided?
  • Was the complication recognized and treated promptly after surgery?
  • What supports the expert's view beyond personal experience: literature, guidelines, or the practice of other surgeons?
  • Does the expert have recent experience with this procedure or with closely related procedures, as the state's qualification rule requires?

Methods

  • Operative report and video review
  • Comparison with recognized operative techniques such as the critical view of safety
  • Postoperative course and complication response review
  • Review of surgical literature on complication rates
  • Analysis of informed consent discussions

How the testimony is attacked

  • Opinion based only on personal experience. Defendants argue that a standard of care opinion needs support beyond the expert's say-so. In Elher v. Misra the Michigan Supreme Court reinstated exclusion of a surgeon's opinion that clipping the common bile duct during a laparoscopic cholecystectomy breached the standard of care, because it rested only on his own views and was contradicted by the published literature.
  • Literature is not always required. Plaintiffs answer that the absence of literature is not decisive. In Danhoff v. Fahim the Michigan Supreme Court held that a trial court abused its discretion by excluding a surgical standard of care expert for failing to cite literature without properly weighing the other reliability factors, and explained that Elher turned on the lack of any support at all.
  • Experience with the specific procedure. Defendants argue the expert must have performed the exact procedure recently. In Dubois v. Brantley the Georgia Supreme Court rejected that reading and held that a surgeon with extensive experience in other abdominal laparoscopic procedures could qualify to criticize a laparoscopic umbilical hernia repair.
  • Different specialty or technique. Courts bar a surgeon from judging a different procedure he is not trained to perform. In Winham v. Reese the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals upheld excluding a retired general surgeon experienced in open surgery from criticizing a gastroenterologist's endoscopic sphincterotomy.
  • Known complication. Defendants stress that bile duct injury and perforation are recognized risks disclosed in consent forms, so the injury alone does not prove negligence.

What the public record shows

Courts have filed at least 33 opinions since 2015 that discuss this class of testimony and cite Daubert or Rule 702, as of October 4, 2026. 5 rulings that show how courts handle this class of testimony:

OutcomeCaseCourtYearWhy
ExcludedElher v. Misra499 Mich. 11Mich.2016The Michigan Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals and reinstated the exclusion of a surgeon's opinion that clipping the common bile duct during a laparoscopic cholecystectomy breached the standard of care, because it rested on his own experience alone and was contradicted by peer-reviewed literature. One justice dissented.
Exclusion reversedDanhoff v. FahimDocket No. 163120Mich.2024In a case over a colon perforated during a lateral spinal fusion, the Michigan Supreme Court held the trial court abused its discretion by excluding the plaintiffs' standard of care expert for lack of supporting literature without properly analyzing the reliability factors, and reversed.
Exclusion reversedDubois v. Brantley297 Ga. 575Ga.2015The Georgia Supreme Court reversed a holding that a surgeon was unqualified to criticize a laparoscopic umbilical hernia repair because he had performed only one such repair in five years, holding that his extensive experience with other abdominal laparoscopic procedures could satisfy the statute.
ExcludedWinham v. Reese2017 OK CIV APP 18Okla. Civ. App.2017The Court of Civil Appeals affirmed excluding a retired general surgeon, experienced in open surgery but not endoscopy, from testifying that a gastroenterologist negligently performed an endoscopic sphincterotomy, and held his opinion on a second physician did not reliably show causation.
ExcludedHeath v. OlavesonHeath v. Olaveson (Idaho June 30, 2026)Idaho2026The Idaho Supreme Court upheld striking an out-of-area general surgery expert's affidavits because they did not show how he learned the local Idaho Falls standard of care or confirmed that it did not differ from the national standard. Conclusory statements that he consulted a local surgeon did not lay the foundation Idaho Code section 6-1013 requires.

Each case links to the free opinion text on CourtListener.

Most of these rulings come from state courts, which apply their own evidence rules: many follow Daubert, some still apply Frye, and a few exempt certain testimony from a reliability hearing altogether. Check which standard governs in your court before relying on a ruling.

In federal court: amended Rule 702

In federal court, since December 1, 2023, Rule 702 says expressly that the party offering an expert must show the court it is more likely than not that the testimony meets each requirement: that it rests on sufficient facts or data, uses reliable methods, and reflects a reliable application of those methods to the case. Questions about the basis of an opinion are no longer automatically matters of weight for the jury. For how the circuits have applied the amendment, see the Rule 702 tracker, which follows each court of appeals; for what that means for preparing or attacking this class of expert, see the guide on amended Rule 702.

Related classes

  • Anesthesiology standard-of-care expert
  • Medical standard-of-care expert
  • Radiology missed-diagnosis expert

Guides

  • Amended Rule 702 After Nearly Three Years: What Courts Exclude
  • Who May Testify to the Standard of Care: Specialty Rules in Malpractice Cases
  • Nurses as Expert Witnesses: Standard of Care and Causation
  • Differential Diagnosis as a Causation Method: What Courts Require

Running this expert agent on a matter

Supreme Mind’s expert agent works from a class of expert, never a named individual, on your fact pattern and returns the likely opinion, the ranked cross-examination weaknesses, the Rule 702 attack surface and what it means for settlement. Read how it works, or book a demo.

Put your questions to this expert.Ask this expertRun it on your matter →

Updated October 4, 2026. How this page is built: rulings are found by searching court opinions on CourtListener. The summaries are written by AI working from the full text of each opinion, and every citation and link is checked automatically. Outcomes are labelled by what the court did with the expert’s testimony. No individual expert is named. This page summarises public decisions for orientation and is not legal advice; read the opinion before relying on any ruling. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Gatekeeper→Expert Agents→Report BuilderOne record, from intake to settlement
Book a demo
Supreme MindSupreme Mind
AI expert witness agents for litigation, from the first screen to settlement
Products
  • Gatekeeper Pilot
  • Expert Agents
  • Report Builder Pilot
  • Pricing
  • Pilots
  • API
  • Use in Claude, ChatGPT, Copilot or Word
  • Book a Demo
Solutions
  • Antitrust
  • Securities
  • Commercial Litigation
  • Mass Tort
  • Personal Injury & Med Mal
  • All Practice Areas
  • For Funders
Why Supreme Mind
  • Expected Gains
  • Benchmark
  • Sample Brief
  • Research
  • Security & Trust
Resources
  • Expert Agent Library
  • Rule 702 Tracker
  • Guides
  • How It Works
  • FAQ
Company
  • About
  • Why Now
  • The Fourth Institution
  • Contact
© 2026 Supreme Mind AI, Inc. All rights reserved.
Terms of ServicePrivacy PolicyDPA